Marketing research has been asking versions of this question for decades. Products and services are not purchased only for what they do. They can also carry socially recognised meanings: taste, status, belonging, values and identity. What we buy, use and display can become a way of communicating both who we are and who we would like to be.
So, if products can become symbols of identity, the more interesting question for marketer is: how are brands turning that into strategy?
Let’s establish one thing first: brands don’t only position the products; they also position who uses it.
Theres a difference between saying:
“a lightweight water bottle that will keep your drink cold for 10 hours”
and:
“the water bottle that will be right next to you at Pilates, and on hot girl walk”
One communicates utility. The other communicates identity.
Both may describe exactly the same product, but the second gives the consumer something beyond functionality: a picture of the kind of life and person, the product belongs to.
Brands can create that identity association in several ways:
Creating a persona.
Brands repeatedly associate themselves with a particular type of person, lifestyle or behaviour. Over time, the consumer doesn't just understand what the product is; they develop an idea of who the product is for. Owning it can then become a way of moving closer to that lifestyle.
Building recognisable aesthetic codes.
Colours, photography, packaging, stores, creators, typography and language can position a brand within a particular cultural world: minimalism, quiet luxury, streetwear, wellness, outdoors culture and so on.
Creating communities and tribes.
Consumers don't only form relationships with brands; they can also identify with the other people who consume them. Ownership becomes a signal of membership: people like me use this.
Connecting consumption to values.
Sustainability, creativity, rebellion, ambition, wellness or exclusivity can all become part of the meaning surrounding a product. Buying it can become a way of signalling those values to ourselves and to others.
Selling the ideal self.
This might be the most interesting one. Marketing is not always saying, “this is who you are.” Sometimes it is saying, “this is who you could become.”
Sometimes we choose brands because they feel like us. Other times, we choose them because they feel like the person we're trying to become.
Stanley is a good example of how dramatically that meaning can shift within the same brand. Its traditional flasks and bottles were associated with durability, practicality and outdoor or work environments. The now-iconic Quencher, however, entered a completely different cultural space: pastel colours, Pilates classes, morning routines, car cup holders and wellness content. The basic function is still simple: keeping a drink cold, but the product has become part of a much broader lifestyle identity. Choosing a Stanley Quencher can therefore mean choosing more than a water bottle; it can also mean choosing what that particular version of Stanley represents.
And perhaps the most interesting part is that brand did not create this identity alone. Consumers helped build it.
